Carmelo's Pizzeria$4.6(2,587)🍽️See Full MenuMenu HighlightsSee Full Menu →Garlic knotsVegetable pizzaMeat pizzaCheese pizza sliceMeatballs (Each)$2.99Add Marinara & Mozzarella$1.50Garlic Toast$2.49Side Salad$2.49SIGNATURE SIDES · 13KIDS MENU · 5DESSERTS · 8From the Kitchen · 4See Full MenuLocation & HoursAddress146 W King St, St. Augustine, FL 32084, USASt Augustine, Florida 32084United StatesGet DirectionsHoursCurrent open or closed status is unavailable.Monday11:00 AM – 10:00 PMTuesday11:00 AM – 10:00 PMWednesday11:00 AM – 10:00 PMThursday11:00 AM – 10:00 PMFriday11:00 AM – 11:00 PMSaturday11:00 AM – 11:00 PMSunday11:00 AM – 10:00 PMContact & LinksContact Information(904) 494-6658About Carmelo's PizzeriaQuaint Italian eatery known for hearty pies, salads & other comfort-food favorites among warm decor.Price rangeinexpensiveGoogle-sourced data last fetched on July 23, 2025. 4.6/5Based on 2,587 reviewsRecent ReviewsView all Google reviews →Shannie S2 weeks agoWonderful "hole in the wall" kind of establishment. It's also attached to a gas station. Location is nice and close to the Historic District, here in St. Augustine. Wait staff is pleasant and professi...Read moreaj sipriano2 weeks agoBest pizza in town! The. Rust is thin and crisp. All.of the deserts are made in house and absolutely delicious! An absolute must when in St Augustine.TARA JONES2 weeks agoWe used DoorDash for delivery and these pizzas are huge!! My family loved the veggie pizza that’s packed with toppings. Kids loved the pepperoni. Def will be back!Tammy R2 weeks agoWe had dinner a Monday around 8 pm. We ordered a 20" pizza (half pepperoni half ortolana), a small Greek salad and calzone (we chose 3 flavors: garlic, spinach and basil). The food took soo much time ...Read moreOra Dennis4 months agoThis was our first time in St Augustine and we stopped in for lunch while seeing the city on the trolly that stopped right by the restaurant. We underestimated how big the pizza was and left with plen...Read moreWhat People Are SayingOverall ExperienceCustomers generally report a positive dining experience, highlighting the delicious food and friendly service. The restaurant appears to be a popular choice for both dine-in and takeout.Customer FavoritesThe calzone and pizza are frequently praised, with the crust being noted for its thinness and crispness. The veggie pizza with abundant toppings is also a customer favorite.Atmosphere & ServiceThe restaurant is described as a "hole in the wall" establishment with a pleasant and professional wait staff, specifically mentioning Alexis. The atmosphere includes booth and table seating, as well as an outside option and a brick bar.Value & QualityThe prices are considered fair, and portion sizes are generous, often resulting in leftovers. The food quality is generally high, with homemade desserts being a highlight.Areas for ImprovementThe pizza could benefit from fresh garlic. Some customers have experienced slow service when dining in.Recent TrendsCustomers appreciate the pizza size and topping abundance, particularly for delivery orders. Repeat visits during trips suggest a consistently positive experience.Frequently Asked QuestionsWhere is Carmelo's Pizzeria located?Carmelo's Pizzeria is located at 146 W King St, St. Augustine, FL 32084, USA.What is the price range at Carmelo's Pizzeria?Carmelo's Pizzeria is listed as inexpensive.Where can I find the hours for Carmelo's Pizzeria?The listed hours for Carmelo's Pizzeria are shown in the Location & Hours section on this page. Hours can change, so confirm before visiting.How can I contact Carmelo's Pizzeria?Call Carmelo's Pizzeria at (904) 494-6658. Ask the restaurant directly about reservations or large parties.Photos of Carmelo's PizzeriaMainNearby RestaurantsOld City House Inn & Restaurant⭐ 4.5St AugustineColumbia Restaurant⭐ 4.4St AugustineCasablanca Inn On The Bay⭐ 4.1St AugustineHarry's Seafood, Bar & Grille⭐ 4.6St AugustineCordova Coastal Chophouse & Bar⭐ 4.1St. Augustine
