1. Home
  2. /
  3. St Augustine
  4. /
  5. Old City House Inn & Restaurant
Old City House Inn & Restaurant in St Augustine, main image

Old City House Inn & Restaurant

$$$
4.5(661)
Restaurant LinkView Photos✦AI Review Summary

Location & Hours

Address

115 Cordova St
St Augustine, Florida 32084
United States
Get Directions

Hours

Current open or closed status is unavailable.

Monday5:00 PM – 9:00 PM
Tuesday5:00 PM – 9:00 PM
Wednesday5:00 PM – 9:00 PM
Thursday5:00 PM – 9:00 PM
Friday5:00 PM – 10:00 PM
Saturday5:00 PM – 10:00 PM
Sunday4:30 PM – 8:00 PM

Contact & Links

Contact Information

(904) 826-0113

Restaurant Link

Visit Restaurant Link

About Old City House Inn & Restaurant

Cozy, romantic Spanish inn dating to 1873, featuring a bar & restaurant plus landscaped grounds.

Price range
expensive

Google-sourced data last fetched on April 20, 2025.

4.5/5
Based on 661 reviews

Recent Reviews

View all Google reviews →

William Byrne

a week ago

This review focuses on the restaurant, not the hotel itself. It’s an incredible establishment. Definitely deserving of consideration for those special occasions. Expect to spend $250 for two. Worth it...

Yanni Eisele

2 weeks ago

Perfect walkable location for historic St. Augustine. Beautiful B&B with beautiful rooms attentive staff and amazing breakfast! Comfortable beds and soft sheets good AC as well as shower and jacuzzi t...

Engi Plyler

3 months ago

Terrible experience in the Old City Restaurant on the New Year eve. Do not know where to start. Our table was reserved at 8:45 p.m. for celebration of the new year. When we came with expectation to ...

Jennifer Lacey

4 months ago

Our party of eight had dinner here after a carriage tour for the night of lights. We visit Saint Augustine once a year for the NOL and have tried out most of the nice restaurants in town.We absolutely...

C C

3 months ago

I had dinner and a glass of wine; not a guest of the inn. I felt a warm welcome when arriving. It is such a charming place! The staff is very knowledgeable about gluten sensitivity and I enjoyed GF cr...

What People Are Saying

Overall Experience

The dining experience appears to be mixed, with reviews ranging from highly positive to very negative, indicating inconsistency in service and execution. While some found it delightful, others experienced significant issues.

Customer Favorites

Crab cakes (specifically gluten-free) are mentioned as a highlight. No other specific dishes were repeatedly praised.

Atmosphere & Service

The restaurant is described as charming, cozy, and lavish, with outside seating available. Service quality varies considerably, with some praising attentive and sweet servers while others report hovering, inattentive service, and issues with management.

Value & Quality

One review mentions expecting to spend $250 for two people, deeming it worth it, while others focus more on the quality of the food and experience than the price point. The quality of meals is described as delicious by some.

Areas for Improvement

Service inconsistency is a significant area needing attention, specifically addressing pushy or inattentive waitstaff and resolving billing discrepancies. Another area for improvement is managing reservation expectations, particularly regarding kitchen and bar closing times.

Recent Trends

More recent reviews highlight extremes in both positive and negative experiences, suggesting a potential decline in service or consistency. Issues with staff attentiveness and billing errors appear in more recent feedback.

Frequently Asked Questions

Where is Old City House Inn & Restaurant located?

Old City House Inn & Restaurant is located at 115 Cordova St, St. Augustine, FL 32084, USA.

What is the price range at Old City House Inn & Restaurant?

Old City House Inn & Restaurant is listed as expensive.

Where can I find the hours for Old City House Inn & Restaurant?

The listed hours for Old City House Inn & Restaurant are shown in the Location & Hours section on this page. Hours can change, so confirm before visiting.

How can I contact Old City House Inn & Restaurant?

Call Old City House Inn & Restaurant at (904) 826-0113. Ask the restaurant directly about reservations or large parties.

Photos of Old City House Inn & Restaurant

Old City House Inn & Restaurant restaurant in St Augustine - main photo
Main
Old City House Inn & Restaurant restaurant in St Augustine - photo 2
Old City House Inn & Restaurant restaurant in St Augustine - photo 3
Old City House Inn & Restaurant restaurant in St Augustine - photo 4
Old City House Inn & Restaurant restaurant in St Augustine - photo 5

Nearby Restaurants

Casablanca Inn On The Bay

Casablanca Inn On The Bay

⭐ 4.1
St Augustine
Columbia Restaurant

Columbia Restaurant

⭐ 4.4
St Augustine
Harry's Seafood, Bar & Grille

Harry's Seafood, Bar & Grille

⭐ 4.6
St Augustine
O C White's Seafood & Spirits

O C White's Seafood & Spirits

⭐ 4.2
St Augustine
South-A-Philly Steaks and Hoagies

South-A-Philly Steaks and Hoagies

⭐ 4.3
St Augustine