Angelo's Coal Oven Pizzeria$$4.4(3,258)Restaurant LinkView Photos✦AI Review SummaryLocation & HoursAddress117 W 57th St, New York, NY 10001, USANew York, New York 10001United StatesGet DirectionsHoursClosed • Opens Today at 11:30 AMMonday11:30 AM - 10:00 PMTuesday11:30 AM - 10:00 PMWednesday11:30 AM - 10:00 PMThursday11:30 AM - 10:00 PMFriday11:30 AM - 11:00 PMSaturday11:30 AM - 11:00 PMSunday11:30 AM - 10:00 PMContact & LinksContact Information(212) 333-4333Restaurant LinkVisit Restaurant LinkAbout Angelo's Coal Oven PizzeriaFamily-friendly pizzeria serving thin-crust pies alongside calzones, pastas & salads.Price rangemoderately pricedGoogle-sourced data last fetched on July 13, 2025. 4.4/5Based on 3,258 reviewsRecent ReviewsView all Google reviews →Josh Westfallin the last weekThis was the best pie I had on my trip to NYC this week. The sauce had great flavor, and the dough was cooked perfectly. The picture was after my friends and I took care of half of it but hopefully it...Read moreNick Milesa week agoThe Old School Round pizza was the best pizza I have had so far. Perfectly thin and crispy. High quality cheese (not greasy) with a complimentary fresh tasting sauce but not acidic. We also split a Ca...Read moreJack Krausea week agoCame here from Dave Portnoy’s rating on one bite. We were given a table in 5 minutes. The inside was beautiful and our waiter was very kind. The pizza was delicious, maybe the best pizza I’ve ever had...Read moreAngelica Montalvo [Diversity & Affirmative Action]2 weeks agoI don't feel great about leaving bad reviews but this is my honest opinion with hopes that it'll improve. We arrived around 12:30 PM on a Sunday afternoon. We were immediately greeted and seated. We ...Read moreMassimo3 months agoWe tried the fettuccine Alfredo and the old fashioned pizza. The pasta was clearly from a box, which was a bit of a letdown, though the sauce and chicken were decent enough to make it passable. The pi...Read moreWhat People Are SayingOverall ExperienceThe restaurant generally provides a positive dining experience, with particular praise for the pizza. However, some inconsistencies in service and food quality have been noted.Customer FavoritesThe "Old School Round" pizza and signature cheese pizza are highly praised for their crust, cheese, and sauce. Pastas, especially those made in-house, are also mentioned favorably.Atmosphere & ServiceThe restaurant's ambiance is described as beautiful and warm, with many customers noting friendly and attentive service. However, one review highlighted a negative experience with a server who was perceived as rude and inattentive.Value & QualityThe quality of ingredients is often described as high, particularly the cheese and tomatoes used in the pizza. One reviewer felt the fettuccine Alfredo used boxed pasta, which was a letdown.Areas for ImprovementService inconsistencies and attentiveness should be addressed to ensure a positive experience for all customers. Attention to pasta quality may also be warranted.Recent TrendsRecent reviews continue to highlight the exceptional quality of the pizza and express strong intentions to return. There is consistent positive feedback regarding pizza.Frequently Asked QuestionsWhere is Angelo's Coal Oven Pizzeria located?Angelo's Coal Oven Pizzeria is located at 117 W 57th St, New York, NY 10001, USA.What is the price range at Angelo's Coal Oven Pizzeria?Angelo's Coal Oven Pizzeria is listed as moderately priced.Where can I find the hours for Angelo's Coal Oven Pizzeria?The listed hours for Angelo's Coal Oven Pizzeria are shown in the Location & Hours section on this page. Hours can change, so confirm before visiting.How can I contact Angelo's Coal Oven Pizzeria?Call Angelo's Coal Oven Pizzeria at (212) 333-4333. Ask the restaurant directly about reservations or large parties.Photos of Angelo's Coal Oven PizzeriaMainMore food guides for New YorkThe 7 Best Pizza Slices in New York City, Ranked7 restaurants →Nearby RestaurantsPark Lane Hotel New York⭐ 4.0New YorkTAO Uptown⭐ 4.2New YorkEllen's Stardust Diner⭐ 4.4New YorkDel Frisco's Double Eagle Steakhouse⭐ 4.5New YorkConnolly's⭐ 4.4New York
