Ranked #1 · 7 Best Pizza Slices in New York City

Joe's Pizza Broadway Menu

24 dishes · Pizza · New York City, NY · $ · Prices in USD

Menu content updated Aug 9, 2026Restaurant website

Browse the published menu with prices below, including Plain Cheese Pizza, Plain Cheese Pie with One Topping, Plain Cheese Pie with Half Topping. Prices and availability may vary — please confirm with the restaurant.

← Back to Joe's Pizza Broadway Visit Restaurant Link

Pies

Plain Cheese Pizza

$29

Melted cheese on a classic pizza crust.

Plain Cheese Pie with One Topping

$33

Classic cheese pie with your choice of one topping.

Plain Cheese Pie with Half Topping

$31

Includes one left half topping.

Plain Cheese Pie with Two Toppings

$35

Classic cheese pie with your choice of two toppings.

Plain Cheese Pie with Three Toppings

$37

Classic cheese pie with three toppings of your choice.

Fresh Mozzarella Pie

$33

Eight slices.

Fresh Mozzarella Pie with Half Topping

$35

Includes one left half topping.

Fresh Mozzarella Pie with One Topping

$37

Eight slices.

White Pie

$33

Eight slices.

White Pie with Half Topping

$35

Eight slices. Includes one left half topping.

White Pie with One Topping

$37

Eight slices.

Sicilian Square Pie

$33

Eight slices.

Sicilian Square Pie with Half Topping

$35

Eight slices. Includes one left half topping.

Sicilian Square Pie with One Topping

$37

Square-cut pie with a rich flavor and your choice of one topping.

#1 of 7 · Ranked by FoodDiscovery

Ordering here? Our #1 pick for Best Pizza Slices in New York City is on this menu

We picked the one item to order first. See our pick before you decide.

Reveal the top item

Supreme

$37

Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, and onion.

MeatLover

$37

Pepperoni, sausage, and meatball.

Veggie Pie

$37

With broccoli, mushrooms, peppers, onions, and olives.

Marinara (Cheese-less)

$26

Classic Neapolitan-style pizza without cheese.

Salads

House Salad (Small)

$11

Fresh mixed greens.

House Salad (Family)

$32

Feeds four to five people.

Beverages

20 oz. Soda

$3.50

Refreshing drink to quench your thirst.

Imported Sodas

$4.50

Made with real cane sugar.

Smart Water

Vitamin Water XXX/Tropical

Menu information is maintained in FoodDiscovery's published menu record. Prices and availability may have changed; confirm with the restaurant.