Mahony's Po-boys

4.4(1,888)

Order Now View Menu AI Review Summary

Location & Hours

Address

3454 Magazine St
New Orleans, Louisiana 70115
United States

Get Directions

Hours

Business Hours Not Set

Please check back later

Contact & Ordering

Contact Information

(504) 766-6697

Preferred Ordering

Order Now

4.4/5

Based on 1,888 reviews

Recent Reviews

View all Google reviews →

Stacy Bollmeyer

2 weeks ago

We were looking for something authentic to New Orleans, outside the commercialized, mass produced foods and the French Quarters. Mahoney’s is a neighborhood bar/grill offering their own twist to loc...

Jacks Mitchell

4 months ago

I’m about to move to NOLA, and I’m excited to become a regular at this place! Incredibly fresh and delicious bread and shrimp, great portions, extremely nice staff and fast service, could not have ask...

David Pressler

5 months ago

I got to say the appetizers were pretty on point. Got the muffaletta egg rolls which were fantastic and the red beans and rice which was also really good. Then ordered the shrimp and sausage Po boy......

Frances zangari

3 weeks ago

Suggested by bartender At St Vincent Hotel, Jimmy. Had a fabulous lunch! Will our server was excellent. Also recommended on Diners Drive and Dives. Fried green tomatoes, wings, red rice & beans....

Courtney Kinne

3 months ago

We stopped here because my Wife wanted a po-boy and this was a quick walk from our hotel. We were greeted by the most welcoming staff! They had the best suggestions for food and per their recommendati...

What People Are Saying

Overall Experience

Diners consistently report a highly positive experience, praising the authentic New Orleans cuisine and friendly atmosphere. The restaurant is often described as a hidden gem or a "hole-in-the-wall" with exceptional food.

Customer Favorites

The shrimp po-boy (especially with sweet glazed bacon), fried green tomatoes, and red beans and rice are consistently praised as standout dishes. Other favorites include the mushroom boudin balls, muffaletta egg rolls, and root beer glazed ham po-boy.

Atmosphere & Service

The restaurant is appreciated for its welcoming and helpful staff, with multiple reviewers specifically mentioning excellent service from individual servers. The ambiance is described as casual and neighborhood-oriented, with the patio being a recommended seating option.

Value & Quality

Customers generally find the portions generous and the prices reasonable, especially considering the amount of food received. The food is frequently described as fresh, flavorful, and authentic.

Areas for Improvement

One reviewer felt the shrimp and sausage po-boy, while generously portioned, lacked a certain depth of flavor. No other specific areas for improvement were mentioned.

Recent Trends

More recent reviews continue to highlight the excellent service and delicious po-boys, reinforcing the restaurant's reputation for authentic New Orleans flavors and a friendly, neighborhood vibe.

Frequently Asked Questions

Where is Mahony's Po-boys located in New Orleans?

Mahony's Po-boys is located at 3454 Magazine St in New Orleans, Louisiana. You can easily find it using the map in our Location section.

What type of food does Mahony's Po-boys serve?

Mahony's Po-boys specializes in local cuisine and is considered a moderately priced restaurant. Po' boys come big & loaded with fillings at this airy, counter-serve sandwich shop & bar.

What are the operating hours of Mahony's Po-boys?

The restaurant has regular business hours that may vary by day. Please see our detailed hours in the Location & Hours section.

Does Mahony's Po-boys take reservations?

You can call (504) 766-6697 to inquire about reservations at Mahony's Po-boys.

Is Mahony's Po-boys good for groups?

Mahony's Po-boys welcomes groups and can typically accommodate larger parties. It's recommended to call ahead at (504) 766-6697 if you're planning to visit with a large group.

Photos of Mahony's Po-boys

Main

Mahony's Po-boys restaurant in New Orleans - photo 2

Mahony's Po-boys restaurant in New Orleans - photo 3

Mahony's Po-boys restaurant in New Orleans - photo 4

Mahony's Po-boys restaurant in New Orleans - photo 5