Blackfly The Restaurant

$$$

4.4(1,363)

Restaurant Link View Photos AI Review Summary

Location & Hours

Address

108 Anastasia Blvd
St Augustine, Florida 32080
United States

Get Directions

Hours

Current open or closed status is unavailable.

Monday4:00 PM – 9:00 PM

Tuesday4:00 PM – 9:00 PM

Wednesday4:00 PM – 9:00 PM

Thursday4:00 PM – 9:00 PM

Friday4:00 PM – 10:00 PM

Saturday4:00 PM – 10:00 PM

Sunday4:00 PM – 9:00 PM

Contact & Links

Contact Information

(904) 201-6300

Restaurant Link

Visit Restaurant Link

About Blackfly The Restaurant

Contemporary seafood joint with vibrant, art-lined walls offering the day's catch, sushi & pizza.

Price range: expensive

Google-sourced data last fetched on April 18, 2025.

4.4/5

Based on 1,363 reviews

Recent Reviews

View all Google reviews →

John Raises

4 weeks ago

Overpriced and disappointing. Tacky decor tries to be more than it is. There is a distance between well done tacky and just cheap tacky, maybe due to the age of the place. Seating wasn’t great, bo...

Mandy May Potter

a month ago

All around a terrific experience. The service was fantastic thanks to our waitress, Caitlin. The poké bowl with ponzu was a refreshing starter that set the tone for the meal nicely. I was almost too f...

Shelsea Pelaez

6 months ago

Food was amazing! On the pricier side but worth every penny since every bite is delicious. Our server Erin was excellent. She was very friendly, professional, and helpful. She even had the kitchen spl...

Moose Kernoff

3 months ago

This must be one the best restaurants in St. Augustine. The food is delicious. I had the lobster Mac and cheese that came with an extra tail on top. First time I have seen that. My wife ordered one of...

G s

3 months ago

During our recent visit to St. Augustine, for the Festival of Lights, we dined at your establishment per the recommendation of our Airbnb host. To provide frank feedback, our server, Cosette B, provi...

What People Are Saying

Overall Experience

The dining experience appears to be mixed, with some customers praising the food and service, while others found it overpriced and disappointing. The average rating suggests a moderate level of satisfaction overall.

Customer Favorites

Lobster Mac and Cheese and the fish specials are highly regarded by customers. The poké bowl and crème brûlée also received positive comments.

Atmosphere & Service

Service is generally viewed positively, with some servers specifically mentioned for their exceptional service. The atmosphere is sometimes loud, detracting from the overall experience for some diners.

Value & Quality

Some customers felt the prices were high compared to the quality of the food, with issues such as overcooked or undercooked food, small portions, and bland flavors mentioned. Others believed the quality justified the higher prices.

Areas for Improvement

Food quality consistency and value for money are key areas for potential improvement. Noise levels could also be addressed to enhance the dining atmosphere.

Recent Trends

Recent reviews highlight concerns regarding the value and food quality relative to the price, as well as inconsistencies in execution of dishes. Some also noted decor that seemed cheap or dated, suggesting a need for refurbishment.