Bagel Supreme | Rutherford

4.2(464)

Restaurant Link View Photos AI Review Summary

Location & Hours

Address

284 Park Ave, Rutherford, NJ 07070, USA
Rutherford, NJ 07070
United States

Get Directions

Hours

Closed • Opens Today at 5:00 AM

Monday5:00 AM - 3:00 PM

Tuesday5:00 AM - 3:00 PM

Wednesday5:00 AM - 3:00 PM

Thursday5:00 AM - 3:00 PM

Friday5:00 AM - 3:00 PM

Saturday5:00 AM - 3:00 PM

Sunday5:00 AM - 3:00 PM

Contact & Links

Contact Information

(201) 460-7775

Restaurant Link

Visit Restaurant Link

About Bagel Supreme | Rutherford

Price range: inexpensive

Google-sourced data last fetched on April 30, 2025.

4.2/5

Based on 464 reviews

Recent Reviews

View all Google reviews →

Celeste C.

6 months ago

This morning, I was craving a bagel. I've passed this place a few times, so I decided to go in. Upon walking in, the establishment is pleasant to the eye. It's adorned with Halloween decorations, whi...

michael volpe

2 months ago

Just ordered two sandwiches, that amounted to over $20, and this is what I got! Literally two pieces of meat on each sandwich! I've never in all my life seen sadder sandwiches. Never again will I come...

D B

2 months ago

Use to go to them every weekend because they were so good. Now they only put one piece of bacon, and one egg. My total with a water was $12. Insane!! Also called, and the lady told me they just starte...

Michael Cicchine

7 months ago

I pass this place every day going to work and decided to bring my boys here and try it out. Nearly $13 for two plain bagels with cream cheese and a whole wheat everything with lox spread. I asked for ...

Brian Ryu

a month ago

I’ve been a Bagel Supreme regular for sometime as it’s a relaxed place to pick up breakfast or stop by for lunch. Most of the time, the person helping me has been great, but I had a bad experience th...

What People Are Saying

Overall Experience

The overall dining experience appears to be generally negative based on the reviews, with notable issues related to pricing, portion sizes, and service inconsistencies. The average rating indicates dissatisfaction among customers.

Customer Favorites

The "everything bagel" is mentioned positively when prepared well. Other specific customer favorites are not consistently identified in the provided reviews.

Atmosphere & Service

The establishment's aesthetic is described as pleasant and "cute" due to decorations. However, service experiences are mixed, with some customers encountering unhelpful or discourteous staff behavior and issues with order accuracy.

Value & Quality

Customers express concerns about the value for money, citing high prices for small portions of ingredients like bacon and meat. The quality of the sandwiches has been criticized, with descriptions of "sad" presentations and insufficient fillings, and some inconsistencies regarding included sides.

Areas for Improvement

Portion control and pricing accuracy, especially regarding advertised inclusions like chips and pickles, need improvement. Staff training to enhance customer service and ensure order accuracy is also necessary.

Recent Trends

Recent feedback indicates declining quality in ingredients (reduced fillings/toppings) and potential price increases for certain menu items. There are also reports about deviations from previously established menu offerings (e.g., changes in included sides) without clear communication to customers.

Frequently Asked Questions

Where is Bagel Supreme | Rutherford located?

Bagel Supreme | Rutherford is located at 284 Park Ave, Rutherford, NJ 07070, USA.

What is the price range at Bagel Supreme | Rutherford?

Bagel Supreme | Rutherford is listed as inexpensive.

Where can I find the hours for Bagel Supreme | Rutherford?

The listed hours for Bagel Supreme | Rutherford are shown in the Location & Hours section on this page. Hours can change, so confirm before visiting.

How can I contact Bagel Supreme | Rutherford?

Call Bagel Supreme | Rutherford at (201) 460-7775. Ask the restaurant directly about reservations or large parties.

Photos of Bagel Supreme | Rutherford

Main

Bagel Supreme | Rutherford restaurant in Rutherford - photo 2

Bagel Supreme | Rutherford restaurant in Rutherford - photo 3

Bagel Supreme | Rutherford restaurant in Rutherford - photo 4

Bagel Supreme | Rutherford restaurant in Rutherford - photo 5