Old Homestead Steakhouse

$$$$

4.1(2,305)

Restaurant Link View Photos AI Review Summary

Location & Hours

Address

56 9th Ave
New York, New York 10011
United States

Get Directions

Hours

Closed • Opens Today at 5:00 PM

MondayClosed

Tuesday5:00 PM - 9:00 PM

Wednesday5:00 PM - 9:00 PM

Thursday5:00 PM - 9:00 PM

Friday5:00 PM - 9:00 PM

Saturday5:00 PM - 10:00 PM

Sunday4:00 PM - 9:00 PM

Contact & Links

Contact Information

(212) 242-9040

Restaurant Link

Visit Restaurant Link

About Old Homestead Steakhouse

Old-world relic (1868-era) serving huge, pricey steaks in a classic, dark-wood setting.

Price range: very expensive

Google-sourced data last fetched on June 21, 2025.

4.1/5

Based on 2,305 reviews

Recent Reviews

View all Google reviews →

Liam Heyl

2 months ago

The best steak I have EVER had. My girlfriend and I went for our anniversary and we were met with wonderful service, stellar appetizers and like I said- the best steak I’ve ever had in my life. We sha...

Gophers MN

3 months ago

I’ve been here many times.The kobe burger is definitely the star of the show. The mashed potatoes as well. The bacon wrapped fillet was four stars. The season potatoes that come with it, not the best....

Johnny Guzman Jr

5 months ago

A Wonderful Christmas Dinner Experience at Old Homestead We recently had our Christmas dinner at Old Homestead for the second year in a row, and once again, we were thoroughly impressed. From the mom...

Sinclair Lim

6 months ago

It is little different type of steak but so juicy and delicious. Nice atmosphere like cozy brownstone. Staff looks nice but lack of communications unfortunately. Behind of my guest, I spoke to the oth...

Warren Park

3 months ago

Sad to report but service at Old Homestead took a nose-dive. Based on my many fond memories eating here pre- covid I took my teenage son to join me on dinner at this old and traditional steak establis...

What People Are Saying

Overall Experience

The restaurant generally provides a positive dining experience, especially for special occasions and repeat customers. The steaks are frequently praised, contributing to a favorable impression.

Customer Favorites

The 40-day dry-aged porterhouse for two and the Kobe burger are highly favored. Mashed potatoes also receive positive mentions.

Atmosphere & Service

The atmosphere is described as cozy, like a brownstone, sometimes dim, but warm and homely. While staff generally appear nice, there have been mentions of communication issues and inconsistent service.

Value & Quality

The steaks are often considered worth the money. However, there is some inconsistency in side dish quality with some items like the seasoned potatoes and unseasoned broccoli receiving negative feedback.

Areas for Improvement

Communication among the staff regarding special requests needs improvement. Also, consistency in food quality, especially with side dishes, could be enhanced.

Recent Trends

A recent review indicates a decline in service quality, with long wait times and issues with side dishes. Prior to this, consistent positive experiences, especially for special occasion dinners, were commonly reported.