Ranked #4 · 7 Best Pizza Slices in New York City

Little Italy Pizza

4.2(4,144)

See Full Menu

#4 of 7Ranked #4 of 77 Best Pizza Slices in New York CitySee who took the top spot

Location & Hours

Address

2 E 33rd St, New York, NY 10016, USA
New York, New York 10016
United States

Get Directions

Hours

Closed • Opens Monday at 5:00 AM

Monday5:00 AM - 3:00 PM

Tuesday5:00 AM - 3:00 PM

Wednesday5:00 AM - 3:00 PM

Thursday5:00 AM - 3:00 PM

Friday5:00 AM - 3:00 PM

Saturday5:00 AM - 3:00 PM

Sunday5:00 AM - 3:00 PM

Contact & Links

Contact Information

(212) 481-5200

Restaurant Link

Visit Restaurant Link

About Little Italy Pizza

Slices on-the-go, New York-style pies & calzones in a counter-service Midtown setting.

Price range: inexpensive

Google-sourced data last fetched on July 28, 2025.

4.2/5

Based on 4,144 reviews

Recent Reviews

View all Google reviews →

Crystal

5 months ago

Never been to a Litty Italy Pizza location. I like that it’s hardly ever packed when I sometimes come for lunch. What I don’t like are the prices but then again it is Manhattan and NYC everything has ...

Sofía Alarcón

3 months ago

The tables were dirty, the service was okay, they were fast. The pizza it's okay, not that good. I think the prices are okay, but I wouldn't go there again. The staff was nice and attentive The good t...

Kim Granger

5 months ago

Wow. This is the most crispy pizza I have ever had. Staff members here are helpful, efficient, busy and kind. "Atmosphere" was 5-star until they turned up this Loud Music 🎶. You choose a slice and ...

Bogoslov Ion

5 months ago

Avoid This Tourist Trap! I went to this pizzeria last night and had a very unpleasant experience. I ordered 4 slices of pizza and 2 draft beers (one large and one small), and I was shocked by the bil...

Charles K

4 months ago

Great pizza. Crunchy crust. It’s the type I enjoy when I come to nyc. Nice and quick service as well. Clean space And most importantly SEATING!!!

What People Are Saying

Overall Experience

The dining experience appears mixed, with some customers enjoying the pizza and service, while others report negative experiences related to pricing and cleanliness. The overall sentiment leans towards average, with concerns impacting customer satisfaction.

Customer Favorites

The crispy pizza, especially the crunchy crust, and regular slices are frequently praised. The availability of a 2-slice and drink deal is also a highlight for some customers.

Atmosphere & Service

Service experiences vary, with some customers describing the staff as nice, attentive, helpful, efficient, and kind, while others reported issues with cashier interactions. Cleanliness of the tables and seating availability are also mentioned as factors affecting the atmosphere.

Value & Quality

Pricing is a significant concern for some, with reports of overcharging and perceived high costs, although others find the prices acceptable considering the location. The pizza quality is generally well-received, with emphasis on the crust's crunchiness and overall flavor.

Areas for Improvement

Cleanliness of tables needs attention, and concerns about potential overcharging and lack of transparent pricing should be addressed. The quality of the garlic knots could also be improved.

Recent Trends

Recent reviews show a mix of positive feedback regarding pizza quality and quick service, alongside negative feedback about potential tourist traps with inflated prices. There are also some inconsistent reports on the attentiveness of the staff.