The Whistle Stop Pub

4.2(650)

Restaurant Link View Photos AI Review Summary

Location & Hours

Address

82685 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036, USA
Islamorada, FL 33036
United States

Get Directions

Hours

Current open or closed status is unavailable.

Monday11:00 AM – 3:00 AM

Tuesday11:00 AM – 3:00 AM

Wednesday11:00 AM – 3:00 AM

Thursday11:00 AM – 3:00 AM

Friday11:00 AM – 3:00 AM

Saturday11:00 AM – 3:00 AM

Sunday11:00 AM – 3:00 AM

Contact & Links

Contact Information

(305) 664-0094

Restaurant Link

Visit Restaurant Link

About The Whistle Stop Pub

Basic pub grub & libations are served in relaxed environs with pool tables & TVs.

Price range: inexpensive

Google-sourced data last fetched on April 29, 2025.

4.2/5

Based on 650 reviews

Recent Reviews

View all Google reviews →

Rebecca Linden

a week ago

Very busy weekend night and they were packed but ended up getting 2 bar seats and a bit loud in there but great music on the juke box and bartenders did their best and soe of the best fish dip ever an...

Angie Junea

11 months ago

So I was down visiting family and one of them suggested the whistle stop. When we walked in we were greeted by two bartenders that quickly made some of the best Long Island ice tea’s. They quickly too...

Taylor Engel, FL Keys Realtor (South Florida Realtor)

a year ago

The locals place for Pizza! 🍕 the best pizza on the island. Whether you pick up and bring home or order there you can be sure your pizza will be hot and packed with flavor!

GrimzFamilyTravel

9 months ago

It's good pizza, our first time ordering a Chicago pizza style. It is very thick and has lots of filling (cheese). The cheese pizza, our kiddos, finish it all.

Kim Darrah

2 years ago

Small unpretentious bar with great pizza and nice people. Usually have the regular double pepperoni round but today tried the Chicago. First time I could only eat 2 pieces! Will order again… Hard n...

What People Are Saying

Overall Experience

The restaurant provides a positive dining experience with a focus on pizza and a casual bar atmosphere. Customers generally report satisfaction with the food and service.

Customer Favorites

Pizza, particularly the Chicago style and double pepperoni, is a clear favorite. Other popular items include the fish dip, wings (especially garlic parmesan), and tacos.

Atmosphere & Service

The restaurant is described as a busy, sometimes loud, "locals place" with a jukebox and pool tables. Customers appreciate the friendly bartenders and attentive service.

Value & Quality

The pizza is consistently praised for being hot, flavorful, and packed with toppings. The cheeseburger and tacos are also considered high quality.

Areas for Improvement

One review mentioned undercooked vegetables on a pizza that had to be sent back to the kitchen.

Recent Trends

Recent reviews highlight the restaurant being busy, especially on weekend nights, and praise the fish dip along with the pizza.

Frequently Asked Questions

Where is The Whistle Stop Pub located?

The Whistle Stop Pub is located at 82685 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036, USA.

What is the price range at The Whistle Stop Pub?

The Whistle Stop Pub is listed as inexpensive.

Where can I find the hours for The Whistle Stop Pub?

The listed hours for The Whistle Stop Pub are shown in the Location & Hours section on this page. Hours can change, so confirm before visiting.

How can I contact The Whistle Stop Pub?

Call The Whistle Stop Pub at (305) 664-0094. Ask the restaurant directly about reservations or large parties.

Photos of The Whistle Stop Pub

Main

The Whistle Stop Pub restaurant in Islamorada - photo 2

The Whistle Stop Pub restaurant in Islamorada - photo 3

The Whistle Stop Pub restaurant in Islamorada - photo 4

The Whistle Stop Pub restaurant in Islamorada - photo 5