$64 for two pizzas (one Hawaiian, one buffalo chicken and bacon) is absolutely RIDICULOUS. NO pizza is worth that much, and especially not this one. I'd be more than happy to pay the price if it actua...

Christian Rodriguez

2 months ago

Best slice in NYC. It can’t get better when you’re able to eat it right when it comes out of the oven.

Samarth Patel

a month ago

Worst Pizzaria in all of brooklyn literally. Delivery took 1 hour 30 mins to deliver a pie 2 blocks. Extremely rude staff giving excuse after excuse. Last order was never even delivered and never got ...

Ives

a year ago

Ordered take out for the supreme meat pizza which was 18”. You could tell they didn’t skimp on the toppings. For 26$ I would say this was worth the price. I also got a side of ranch and marinara sauce...

Daniel Pino

8 months ago

Luigi’s Pizza Layout/atmosphere *Seven tables in the back Food/drink *Regular slice - solid; flop; decent crust *Square slice - good; cheesy

What People Are Saying

Overall Experience

The reviews present a mixed dining experience, with some customers praising the pizza quality and others criticizing the price, service, and delivery. The overall sentiment is somewhat neutral, with a moderate average rating.

Customer Favorites

The supreme meat pizza and square slice received positive mentions. The regular slice was also considered a solid choice.

Atmosphere & Service

The restaurant has seven tables in the back. Negative comments include rude staff, poor communication when ordering, and slow or undelivered orders.

Value & Quality

Some customers found the pizza overpriced, especially considering the perceived blandness. Others felt the supreme meat pizza was worth the price due to generous toppings.

Areas for Improvement

Delivery speed and staff communication skills need improvement. Order accuracy and reliability should also be addressed.

Recent Trends

Recent reviews highlight concerns about high prices and issues with order accuracy and delivery. One recent review specifically cited bland pizza and poor phone ordering experience.

Frequently Asked Questions

Where is Luigi’s Pizza located in Brooklyn?

Luigi’s Pizza is located at 4704 5th Ave in Brooklyn, New York. You can easily find it using the map in our Location section.

What type of food does Luigi’s Pizza serve?

Luigi’s Pizza specializes in local cuisine and is considered a affordable restaurant. Basic neighborhood pizzeria offering slices & other Italian classics with some modern touches.

What are the operating hours of Luigi’s Pizza?

The restaurant has regular business hours that may vary by day. Please see our detailed hours in the Location & Hours section.

Does Luigi’s Pizza take reservations?

You can call (718) 492-7565 to inquire about reservations at Luigi’s Pizza.

Is Luigi’s Pizza good for groups?

Luigi’s Pizza welcomes groups and can typically accommodate larger parties. It's recommended to call ahead at (718) 492-7565 if you're planning to visit with a large group.

Photos of Luigi’s Pizza

Main

Luigi’s Pizza restaurant in Brooklyn - photo 2

Luigi’s Pizza restaurant in Brooklyn - photo 3

Luigi’s Pizza restaurant in Brooklyn - photo 4

Luigi’s Pizza restaurant in Brooklyn - photo 5